Friday, August 22, 2014

Susceptible to Ebola, immune to criticism

Karl Marx famously wrote that "... philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it." The quote by Marx is sometimes used to bash 'academics' in the name of world-changers, men (and women) of enterprise, the 'hands-on' types, interveners, implementers, and so on: what we need is action, not thinking! This, of course, this turns Marx into a cartoon. If he knew the shortcomings of thought without action, Marx also recognised the perils of action without thought. Marx was a German philosopher. He thought for a living. But that hasn't stopped lesser minds from treating action as if it were a good in itself, something we should not distract with reflection or critique. Just do it.

I read today an opinion piece in US Today that brought the above thoughts to mind. In it, Franklin Graham, the head of the evangelical/relief organisation Samaritan Purse, claims that there is no ethical issue involved in providing Dr. Kent Brantly (employee of Samaritan Purse) privileged access to a experimental drug for his Ebola infection. Those who think there are ethics to debate here are merely intellectual elites ('academics' , 'talking heads' ) far removed from 'primitive deathbeds' in Africa, and the ethical debate -- politically correct analysis from the cozy confines of America -- does nothing to help save people at death's door. Dr. Brantly, the piece goes on, left the comforts of America to provide medical assistance in Liberia, got infected with Ebola in the process, and what happens when he gets access to the scarce experimental treatment? People debate about whether that is ethical or not. This is outrageous, because:

this drug is being used to save a doctor who will say thank you by returning to some of the darkest, dirtiest, loneliest places on earth to bring hope and healing to others. What is the ethical dilemma in that equation?

It is hard to know where to start. I suppose the first point to consider would be the neo-colonial, 'Heart of Darkness' description of someone else's country as the 'darkest, dirtiest, and loneliest places on earth.' Apparently the dark, dirty and lonely people should simply be grateful for whatever help they manage to get, and if American academics say anything, they should be singing the praises of the organisation's humanitarian actions. Therein lies another assumption: if you save the lives of individuals, or if your organisation has the mission to save the lives of individuals, then any critical perspective on you or your organisation is inappropriate. Medical humanitarian organisations sometimes take this defensive stand, despite empirical studies that have shown that they are (predictably) a complicated source of good and bad, rife with ethical challenges, like any other sort of human institution. And as for the assumption is that only faraway American academics have the luxury to raise ethical concerns about giving privileged access to experimental treatment to an American doctor and missionary, i.e. people unfamiliar with and untouched by African realities ... think again. The ethical questions around this issue are being debated within Africa, by Africans, as well. Africans also think about issues of global inequality and injustice when they see socio-political elites being whisked off to superior health care, not just when Westerners get sick and get evacuated to the better hospitals in the brighter/cleaner/happier countries, but also when their own political leaders get sick and are flown up to fancy clinics in Paris or London. It is not politically correct analysis, it is painful reality.

The story about the Americans gaining access to the experimental Ebola treatment does reveal something about the state of the world, including its ethics. Debating the ethics is not inappropriate, nor does it hinder efforts to control Ebola. To see this though, you have to move beyond the missionary position.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, July 02, 2014

Bring out your infected!

Public health emergencies reveal a brutal survivalist ethic within societies that normally lies suppressed. Normally, we are supposed to care about the individual choices of fellow citizens and protect their rights, but when an easily transmissible, life-threatening and incurable disease spreads in communities and exceeds our control efforts, rights and choices are transformed into dangerous niceties. That is when the sharper tools in the public health toolbox get pulled out: the involuntary interventions for the common good, the isolation, the quarantine, the mandatory testing. This all sounds routinely ethically justified in a robust, hard-headed, no-nonsense utilitarian sort of way. But there is a plot twist: you don't want the sharp tools to scare or alienate the population so much that they run alway from (or sabotage) public health efforts altogether. Tough love can have perverse outcomes.

Which reminds me of Ebola. As an educator in bioethics, whenever you want to provide an example of a disease that seems to ethically justify industrial-strength public health actions, Ebola fits the bill  even better than HIV or TB. Easy to contract, impossible to cure, and associated with a nasty clinical presentation and a very high mortality rate, Ebola evokes extreme fear that makes extreme responses to it seem commonsensical. This seems to be the case in Liberia at the moment. West Africa is undergoing an Ebola epidemic, and for its part, Liberia has had 61 cases in the past few months, with 41 deaths. The response? Liberia President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf has declared that anyone caught hiding suspected Ebola virus disease (EVD) patients will be prosecuted under Liberian law.

Will this way of 'being serious about the epidemic' help with disease control or quite the opposite? Families and religious organisations currently taking care of/harboring those with Ebola-like symptoms will probably need to be reassured that these patients will be given respectful, effective care. Shouting at caregivers of the sick may not work, particularly when you realise that when you hand someone with Ebola over to the health authorities, it may be the last you see of them.

Labels: , , ,