Wednesday, September 27, 2017

Trying to look on the bright side of colonialism

There has been a big flap this week about an article published in Third World Quarterly entitled 'The Case for Colonialism' by Bruce Gilley at Portland State University. The controversy seemingly revolves around how the article was published by the journal's editor despite having been rejected by its reviewers, i.e. a violation of the peer review process. But, of course, the complaints are not purely about the process of the paper coming to light: after all, the author is arguing that colonialism was largely a good thing, and we should have more of it. There would be much less political buzz if the journal's editor had, over the objections of reviewers, approved a paper called 'The Case Against Colonialism.'

As for the paper itself, it is something of a train wreck, and there is a strong case for thinking the reviewers (whose reviews are apparently under lock and key) were right. Gilley maps out a series of epistemic virtues (non-biased data and case selection, internal coherence, falsifiability of claims), which he uses to criticize those opposed to colonialism. In the course of building his own argument, however, he violates all of them, and how. You could base a drinking game on how many times he hoists himself on his own petard. Just one example: Gilley claims that colonialism had 'subjective legitimacy' because, he writes, the colonized populations generally approved of colonial powers and governance. His 'data' for this sweeping claim throughout the paper largely comes in the form of journalistic impressions and anecdotal remarks. This is not the worst of it. As others have pointed out, the most damning problem with the article is his relentless cherry-picking of benefits from colonial rule together with a complete disregard for the long-term and widespread damage colonial rule caused or the self-serving and usually racist motivations behind it. It does not take much effort to see the piece, particularly in the current US political climate, as historical revisionism in the service of white supremacy. No doubt defenders of such views will object that academia should be open to 'alternative voices' in the name of the First Amendment. But academic journals have no obligation to be open to crappy papers.

What could have been more interesting, instead of making a case for colonialism, is a critical analysis of the myriad ways former colonies grapple with the legacies of colonialism, since they are typically unable to fully embrace or reject them. Whatever 'benefits' might be attributed to colonialism cannot be disentangled from harms and violations; there are no real concepts to faithfully describe this. Tainted benefits? Abuses with an upside? When you drive the N1 out of Cape Town in South Africa, you are enjoying one of the best highways in Africa. You are also 'enjoying' the fruits of the Apartheid system, built by cheap labor, and as you drive, you can see townships where populations of non-whites were dumped and continue to experience the effects of political oppression. Reading Gilley is like hearing someone say: "Get over it. Don't you see you have a highway? So blind, so ungrateful."

Is there a link here to bioethics? I think so. Bioethics workers in developing countries are in a similarly uncomfortable position of being unable to fully reject assumptions, preoccupations and frameworks originating from the richer countries of the north, but also unable to fully embrace them without losing touch with (and being useful for) their own local context. The decolonization of bioethics in Africa, whose shape is hard to discern, will be a long work in progress.

Labels: , , , ,

18 Comments:

Blogger Kamilla Rott said...

My advice for new bloggers is… give it a go, and persist! If you enjoy it and are passionate about it, and you share that enjoyment and passion with students, they want to be involved in it! PhDify.com
Good luck for the start of term this week!
I found your post really helpful. My Y2 class and I have only been blogging since Sept but, in this short time, it has become a really important tool in so many different ways

10:14 AM  
Blogger anna koera said...

Wel once again Check in detail on Kerala SSLC as wel as
Check on Kar SSLC and 2018 is much awaited for
SSLC Result Tamilnadu

12:34 PM  
Blogger Aadi Rane said...

valentine day message to husband
simple message on valentine day for wife
romantic teddy day messages for grilfriend
greetings teddy day message for him
promise day message for hubby
quotes on promises day cards for wife

1:33 AM  
Blogger Rohit Kulegi said...

great information.
CreeHack
CreeHack APK
in app purchase hack android
My Android
Android and iOS apps
Hacking Apps
Android Applications

9:49 PM  
Blogger عبدالله السيد said...

اذا كانت تبحث عن شركة تنظيف بالرياض مجربه له اسما عريق ولديها الخبره فى التنظيف عليك الاتصال على شركة ركن كلين لخدمات التنظيف بالرياض اذا كانت تبحث عن المعدات والاجهزه والاسعار المناسبه لك على التوصل مع شركتنا لان لديها عروض خاصه واسعار مناسبه لكل عملاء.
شركة نظافة بالخرج
تتشرف شركة تنظيف موكيت بالخرج وتتقدم شركتنا بخدماتها مع فريق من المتخصصين والخبراء فى تنظيف وصيانه وكل مايتعلق بها من اعمال التنظيف ومكافحة الحشرات.
شركتنا شركة تنظيف منازل بالخرج سوف نساعك فى الحصول على أفضل خدمات تنظيف البيوت والمنازل فى أقل وقت وبدون مجهود وبجودة فائقه لم تحصلى عليها من قبل وسوف تستعيدى جمال منزلك المبهر والمميز.
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالخرج
شركة تنظيف مساجد بالخرج
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالخرج
شركة رش مبيدات بالخرج


7:34 AM  
Blogger Jintom Paul said...

We will get all information regarding the Kerala SSLC results 2018kerala sslc resultsPlease click on this link

6:30 AM  
Blogger Jintom Paul said...

We will get all information regarding the Karnataka SSLC results 2018Karnataka SSLC ResultsPlease click on this link

12:40 AM  
Blogger Jintom Paul said...

We will get all information regarding the Karnataka PUC results 2018puc resultsPlease click on this link


Complete information regarding 2nd PUC Results 20182nd puc results 2018On a single click

11:26 PM  
Blogger Jintom Paul said...

We will get complete information of Tamilnadu HSC Results 2018tamilnadu hsc results 2018Just click on this link

11:49 PM  
Blogger Assignment Help said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

3:24 AM  
Blogger Jintom Paul said...

We will get complete information of Tamilnadu SSLC Results 2018tamilnadu sslc results 2018Just click on this link

11:55 PM  
Blogger Jintom Paul said...

This is nice to hear that we will get the complete details of SSLC results 2018 of Kerala statekerala sslc results 2018by just clicking on this link

1:36 AM  
Blogger Jintom Paul said...

We will get complete and detailed information of Kerala Plus Two Results 2018Kerala Plus Two Results 2018On a simple on this link

10:57 PM  
Blogger Jintom Paul said...

We will get complete and detailed information of Kerala Plus Two Results 2018Kerala DHSC Results 2018On a simple on this link

3:44 AM  
Blogger acep saepul milah said...

Our instructors ought to take more imaginative strategies for educating our youngsters. Numerous schools in our nation still take the customary technique for instructing.
Walatra Sehat Sendi |
Walatra Sehat Sendi |
Walatra Sehat Sendi |
Walatra Sehat Sendi |
Walatra Sehat Sendi |

11:38 PM  
Blogger Daniel Potter said...

Great article. And very informative. It's interesting to follow your arguments. Find efficient help for dissertation abstracts online.

4:10 AM  
Blogger Jobs News24 said...

Your Blog all Post information is very unique and good for reader because when i have read your blog looks very impressive for me. I want to say thanks to you. Most importantly I have bookmark your site for future updates.I’m just waiting for your next update to come as I like all your posts.I also recommend your visitors to read here for job circular 2018 . Thank you so much...

10:58 AM  
Blogger VAT UAE said...


The VAT has changed the system of business in UAE and most of the business trust over Top Dubai Auditors to manage their updates yearly, monthly or even quarterly to achieve the target. Well, this year is so crucial and auditors in town are rushing to update the accounts even so fast and better manner. The leading Top 10 Best UAE Audit Firms representing the honorable function over best auditing firm of this year in a surprising event.

11:17 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home