Saturday, August 19, 2017

Lessons from the West African Ebola epidemic

Conventional wisdom—and an article in the Journal of Medical Ethics reviewed on this blog two years ago—advise that health research should not be conducted during times of crisis. Yes, such conditions compromise the controlled environments that studies typically require to produce reliable results, but they can also threaten the ethical integrity of research. Without institutional mechanisms to hold them accountable, investigators may cut corners, violate standards of privacy and informed consent, and even endanger participants. Disruption in the normal function of medical services can also apply pressure on individuals unable to access care by traditional means to seek it out by participating in risky research. And even if one assumes that researchers display honesty beyond reproach, it is still unreasonable to expect that they would be able to keep their cool in the midst of widespread panic and social collapse. But there is a fly in the ointment, at least when it comes to crises caused by epidemics. Public health organizations are first-responders at these moments, but they would be dead in the water without relevant data collected under real-world conditions to guide their actions. In this situation, the precautionary principle alone is not enough to stop a study altogether. In fact, it could be argued that an absolute prohibition against biomedical research in such situations may itself be unethical. The question then becomes, not whether, but how to guarantee ethical research during outbreaks?
The Ethics Review Board (ERB) of Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) had to contend with this question during the 2014 Ebola epidemic. They recently chronicled their experience in the April issue of Public Health Ethics. Beyond the herculean task of evaluating 27 research proposals in the space 12 months—40% of which required review by the entire board—, they had to take into account the extremely vulnerable environment in which investigators intended to operate.
They noted critical ethical shortcomings in many of the studies they reviewed. Perhaps the most significant was the failure of many researchers to engage substantively with local ethical review committees. As a result, several studies did not develop adequate protocols to deal with the collection and storage of blood samples. This was particularly troubling in light of the importance many local communities attach to human blood.  While the MSF ERB is to be commended for its remarkable performance under considerable pressure, the authors’ account suggests areas for improvement. The article does not mention whether the MSF ERB considered that the studies under review could implicitly coerce participation in exchange for care. This is a tricky ethical dilemma to work through. Normal medical systems were entirely overwhelmed in West Africa; many in need of treatment had no other recourse to access care. Those who had contracted the virus might feel that involvement in research—even if it was risky or poorly understood—was their only option. Can participants grant true informed consent under such pressure? However, there is a counter argument to consider. These studies could offer some semblance of medical services, perhaps even life-saving ones, in places where there previously were none. Is it really ethical to deny this opportunity simply because a study fell short of perfection? Is no choice better than a forced choice? These questions have no easy answers, but they certainly are ones that ERBs should grapple with. In the words of the authors, “ethics corner-cutting is neither justified nor necessary even in an emergency.” Public health research during times of crisis or disruption may be a necessity. However, this is no excuse for slipshod consideration of ethical consequences, whether by researchers or review boards alike.
Gaelen Snell 

Labels: , , ,

31 Comments:

Blogger Aryan Arps said...

Nice Information. Thanks for sharing such a nice information.
exams
healthcare
lifestyle
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nice Information. Thanks for sharing such a nice information.
competition
engineering
law
mba
school
medical

12:28 AM  
Blogger Kang Herbal said...

Already annoyed with a black slug, long and hard to lose ?? Looking For How To Eliminate Existing Natural Bugs are really powerful efficacious ?? Here we will address it for you a proven and potent way to remove former budugs in a short time.
Obat Lipoma
Cara Menghilangkan Bekas Budug Secara Alami
Cara Mengobati Sekelan
Cara Mengobati Lipoma Menggunakan Kunyit
Obat Mata Panda Di Apotik
Obat Gudik Resep Dokter
Obat Pilek Menahun Pada Anak
Cara Meluruskan Mata Juling

2:14 AM  
Blogger anna koera said...

Let us celebrate this
New year 2018 and
Merry Christmas 2017 Day by sharing beautiful
Christmas Greetings 2017
Happy Christmas Sayings to our loved one.

12:28 PM  
Blogger Wildan Backlink said...

Very good information. Very helpful for my work
Cara Pemesanan Walatra Sehat Mata Softgel
Obat Mata Juling
Obat Mata Berlemak Resep Dokter Di Apotik

3:10 AM  
Blogger Risna Aryani said...

Obat TBC Generik Resep Dokter Di Apotik

Obat TBC Resep Dokter Di Apotik

1:38 AM  
Blogger Aadi Rane said...

valentines weekquotes for friends and family
happy valentines weekmessages for girlfriend
roses day messages for boyfriend
images of happy rose day message for grilfriend

1:34 AM  
Blogger Risna Aryani said...


https://obatnyerisendidiapotek.blogspot.co.id

3:13 AM  
Blogger Rino Febri said...

Thank you for sharing information about health :-)
Obat Kista 6,7 dan 8 Cm
Obat Tinea Capitis
Cara Mengobati Keringat dingin
Obat Keringat Dingin Herbal
Obat ITP Di Apotik Untuk Anak
Obat Herbal Penyakit Muntaber

8:36 PM  
Blogger rumah walatra said...

This obat amandel tanpa operasi is the most interesting information and fit into our topic. I want to share it with my friends

10:12 AM  
Blogger Indriani Winie said...

May be bestowed a lot of sustenance
Cara Mengobati Tumit Sakit Ketika Berjalan

2:53 AM  
Blogger Herbal Mart said...

Warm greetings from us
Testimoni Obat Syaraf Kejepit QnC Jelly Gamat

10:04 PM  
Blogger rumah walatra said...

This is the most interesting information and fit into our topic. I want to share it with my friends
obat penggemuk badan

11:01 PM  
Blogger Naura Nut said...

Hopefully there is an easy way to achieve success
Obat Herbal Untuk Pegal Linu Akibat Rematik
Cara Mengobati Vitiligo Secara Alami

11:33 PM  
Blogger Reby267 said...

Hopefully more luck
Cara Mengobati Rematik Yang Tidak Kunjung Sembuh
Cara Mengobati Kaki Bengkak Akibat Asam Urat
Cara Efektif Mengobati Saraf Terjepit

3:38 AM  
Blogger Admin Online said...

Bless the blessed sustenance
Cara Mengobati Panu Menahun Agar Tidak Kambuh Lagi
Obat Pengapuran Sendi Herbal Di Apotik
Cara Mengobati Vitiligo Secara Alami

10:30 PM  
Blogger Risna Aryani said...

Best seller and realy yes


Bisakah Mata Minus Disembuhkan

1:39 AM  
Blogger Reby267 said...

Have a good day
Obat Infeksi Tulang Paling Ampuh Dan Efektif

3:37 AM  
Blogger Indriani Winie said...

Hopefully you can get satisfying results
Obat Oles Untuk Eksim Di Apotik

11:13 PM  
Blogger PGA Championship said...

https://pga-championship.de/
PGA Championship
PGA Championship 2018
US PGA Championship
US PGA Championship 2018
h2018 PGA Championship
The PGA Championship
hThe PGA Championship 2018
PGA Championship 2018 Tee Times
hPGA Championship 2018 Leaderboard
PGA Championship 2018 Schedule


https://pgapgachampionship.com/
GA Championship
PGA Championship 2018
US PGA Championship
US PGA Championship 2018
2018 PGA Championship
The PGA Championship
hThe PGA Championship 2018
PGA Championship 2018 Tee Times
PGA Championship 2018 Leaderboard
PGA Championship 2018 Schedule

2:32 PM  
Blogger Giveaway said...

Hopefully it can be more useful
Cara Efektif Mengobati Saraf Terjepit
Obat Radang Lambung Herbal Di Apotik
Cara Mengobati Gondok Beracun Secara Alami

10:21 PM  
Blogger sayyidul ayyam said...

Hopefully more blessings
Cara Mengatasi Susah Bab Pasca Operasi
Penyebab Sendi Bunyi Saat Digerakan

3:39 AM  
Blogger tepong vespa said...

Hopefully it could be better
Cara Mengobati Lipoma Tanpa Operasi
Cara Mengatasi Varises Pada Buah Zakar

10:30 PM  
Blogger Naura Nut said...

Happy Weekend
Obat Untuk Sembelit Pada Anak
Cara Konsumsi QnC Jelly Gamat Untuk Diabetes

2:58 AM  
Blogger Ujang Kulub said...

Hopefully it will be easier to get a fortune
Obat Tipes Herbal Untuk Anak
Cara Mengobati Gondok Beracun Paling Ampuh
Cara Menyembuhkan Varikokel Ringan Secara Alami
Cara Mengobati Sakit Gigi Yang Sering Kambuh

11:14 PM  
Blogger elmo tion said...

Hopefully given the ease of getting what you want
Cara Mengatasi Sakit Ulu Hati Karena Maag
Cara Mengobati Mual Akibat Asam Lambung

11:03 PM  
Blogger Raska Herbal said...

Happy weekend and happy holiday
Penjual Obat Gondok Herbal Di Makassar

11:01 PM  
Blogger Admin Online said...

Have a good day
Bahaya Pilek Menahun Pada Anak dan Cara Pengobatannya

3:39 AM  
Blogger Matak Soak said...

I am very grateful for today's sustenance
Cara Menghilangkan Panu Yang Membandel Secara Alami
Cara Mengatasi Penyakit Lambung Bengkak

10:58 PM  
Blogger Reby267 said...

Have a nice day
Cara Pengobatan Abses Payudara Secara Alami
Obat Radang Sendi

3:09 AM  
Blogger Aang Jauhari said...

Hope to be number one
Obat Lipoma Di Apotik
Cara Mengatasi Pilek Menahun Pada Orang Dewasa
Cara Ampuh Menyembuhkan Flu Tulang

11:35 PM  
Blogger Indriani Winie said...

Hopefully facilitated and launched the way of sustenance
Cara Menyembuhkan Penyakit Diabetes Kering Secara Alami
http://bit.ly/2yVWS0k

2:33 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home