Thursday, August 16, 2012

Surrogate motherhood in developing countries: fine in theory, nasty in practice

Medical tourism is a burgeoning global industry. The nature of the market is governed by economic realities: demand for medical services comes from those with money (normally, those from affluent nations) and the supply or execution of those services fall to entities in developing countries. Consider the growing “rent-a-womb” business in which couples from wealthy nations outsource gestation to surrogate laborers abroad, especially in India. The practice has been hailed as a win-win for both the couple and surrogate mother, most notably on Oprah in 2007. Frustrated couples who have exhausted fertility options and/or cannot afford surrogacy in their home countries take advantage of a cheaper alternative abroad and ultimately return home with a smiling (or crying) baby in arm; on the other hand, surrogate mothers earn sums they could only have dreamed of previously, creating, presumably, a brighter future for their families.

But if one digs beneath the warm, fuzzy veneer projected by the industry, one finds an undersoil less fruitful than a surrogate mother’s womb. Mother Jones recently published an exposé of the industry that reveals unfortunate realities on the ground. For example, surrogate “laborers,” the poverty-stricken carriers of privileged Western fetuses, are often required to live in modest residential dormitories away from their families for the entire duration of the pregnancy, resigning their freedom of movement. New economies are developing as outgrowths of the industry as “recruiters” are hired to scour the slums for women open to the surrogacy-for-money scheme. Exploitation becomes an ethical consideration whenever there is a hierarchical system in which the wealthy seek services from the poor. When a woman living in the slums of Chennai is offered money (a fortune to her and a mere drop-in-the-bucket for her hirer) to lease her womb to a Western couple for 9 months, how much of a choice actually exists when the alternative is the status quo? Poverty is the figurative gun held to the woman’s head as she mulls her “choice.”

There are even larger questions, however. Should surrogate motherhood be forbidden as in some countries like the Netherlands, France, and Japan? If not, should surrogate motherhood be strictly voluntary without any financial incentive? One thing is for sure: if the practice of surrogacy is to continue (which I believe it should, as an option for those couples who have exhausted all other avenues to fertility), it needs to be regulated to reduce exploitation and protect the rights of surrogate mothers. As it stands today there “are no rules” regarding surrogacy in India according to a local health official. No official guidelines exist on a local or national level in India, and the entire industry operates un-policed. But the acts of surrogacy—carrying a fetus and enduring labor—are not benign undertakings devoid of risk, and those bearing these risks deserve protections. Who, for example, should cover the costs associated with a surrogate mother’s health care should she develop a condition related to childbearing in the perinatal period? Unfortunately, the case of Easwari, a surrogate mother who died of severe post-partum hemorrhage, illuminates the industry’s lack of preparedness to deal with these situations. Easwari was told that no help could be found at the clinic that had hired her and was instructed to pay her own transport expenses to a local hospital. She died en-route. Responsibility for the surrogate mother’s health care ended at delivery, apparently.

Guest post by David Kennedy,
Medical student, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill

11 Comments:

Blogger pegge lee said...

Thanks for sharing the blog.I wish you to post the new updates regularly.

gotowe prace dyplomowe

8:50 AM  
Blogger wecare surrogacy said...

There are various countries that offer world-class fertility treatments at very minimal costs, however India is considered to be the major and important destination for the IVF patients from the western world. Apart from attaining important savings, IVF Doctors India are using the most recent technology and medical acquaintance and this is why you can easily make use of your money and time when you plan to visit India for IVF treatment. There are several reasons for considering India to be a feasible option and alternate to other IVF services.
IVF Centres in Mumbai
laparoscopic myomectomy
Cost of IVF in Mumbai
Surrogate Mother India

4:39 AM  
Blogger Sankar Kumar said...

Surrogacy is the arrangement by which a woman conceives, carries and delivers a child for another couple or individual. This woman is known as a surrogate mother or a gestational carrier. If you are thinking to go INDIA for IVF surrogacy, then you must search for Surrogacy India, Surrogate mother India, IVF India, IVF clinic India & IVF cost india. I found Go Surrogacy for this treatment in India. Hope you also like these.

2:51 PM  
Blogger Sankar Kumar said...

Surrogacy is the arrangement by which a woman conceives, carries and delivers a child for another couple or individual. This woman is known as a surrogate mother or a gestational carrier. If you are thinking to go INDIA for IVF surrogacy, then you must search for Surrogacy India, Surrogate mother India, IVF India, IVF clinic India & IVF cost india. I found Go Surrogacy for this treatment in India. Hope you also like these.

3:11 PM  
Blogger Kiran IVF said...

Doctors at Kiran Infertility Centre that gets around 120 foreign nationals for Surrogacy In India say the move will be a drain on the economy.Dr Samit Sekhar, chief embryologist and surrogacy and IVF program director, said that as per the new directive, except a foreign "man and woman" who have been married for a period of at least two years, no one else will be eligible to have an Indian surrogate bear their child.

9:18 AM  
Blogger jimmy wilson said...

Fantastic submit I like your current document; enjoy how you explained all things, you are doing a terrific employment a lot of others as if you by way of which sort of beneficial websites produce consciousness to help us all related to several things. I study a few other interesting websites through your web sites and also We are so much engaged with all your blogging abilities, I likewise started to generate article and this also form dialogue actually support me personally out. My partner and i previously added ones web site as well as propagated your current websites for you to my co-workers besides everyone yet these people like your current running a blog abilities, trust an individual generate much more useful blogs this way 1 and all the best . on your foreseeable future websites.

Jimmy Wilson-Resident Evil Jackets for Sale

9:27 PM  
Blogger sandeep suravarapu said...

Welcome to Kiran Infertility Center! The

surrogacy and infertility super-specialty clinic.

The desire to have a baby is one of life's most

important and exciting decisions. We at KIC,

provide the latest updated technology and

expertise, with the help of world class equipment

and personalized care for for making your dream

come true.

12:35 AM  
Blogger sandeep suravarapu said...

Using a surrogate mother that is surrogacy is still somewhat controversial. But it is one more option people have for having a baby through new reproductive technologies.

8:04 AM  
Blogger ClinicBy Choice said...

Surrogacy is one of the best way to get the child for those couples who is not able to give birth to a child due to some health issues problems.




IVF Treatment in Delhi || IVF Treatment in Jalandhar

5:33 AM  
Blogger Sem Angel said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

7:50 AM  
Blogger Sumita Sofat said...

Just make your appointment with the finest IVF centre in Jalandhar, if you want the best solution for infertility treatment at low prices.

9:18 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home