Saturday, April 16, 2011

The globalization of research ethics committees: paternalism, ethical imperialism or partnership

Research, the story goes, has become increasing global: there is more clinical and behavioral research involving human participants in more places in the world now than ever before in human history. These things don't just happen, so it is interesting to reflect on the meaning of the march of research to all points of the compass. Is it because there is an overwhelming humanitarian concern about those who are sick in the most impoverished areas of the world? Or is it because far-flung (at least, from North America and Europe) countries are a friendly business environment as health-related research becomes more and more about developing profitable interventions and devices?

As research projects and institutions are rapidly springing up around the world like mushrooms, the development of ethics committees to review such research globally is moving at a much more leisurely pace. In many places in Africa, for instance, there is no local body with the authority or expertise to conduct an adequate ethical review of a scientific protocol. In this month's issue of Tropical Medicine and International Health (subscribers only, alas) Ravinetto et. al. argue that there always ought to be a double ethics review of research conducted/sponsored by foreign institutions in developing countries. The requirement for 'local' review -- in addition to review in the sponsor's institution -- appears in some ethics guidelines, and it does happen a good percentage of the time. But why ought it to happen? According to Ravinetto et. al., it ought to happen in order to produce a more comprehensive and balanced review process, which in turn better fulfills the central mission of ethics committees, i.e. to protect research participants and benefit communities affected by the research. A collaborative double review can avoid ethical imperialism (imposition of ethical standards of the richer countries on the poorer ones) and paternalism (in the assumption that only ethics committees in richer countries can really review research adequately). The current problem with double review (according to Ravinetto et. al.) is not just the unpleasant fact that some ethics committees in developing countries may be operating at a low standard. The problem is that ethics committees involved in the review of research often do not correspond with one another at all, and the possible benefits of collaboration are missed.

The points are well taken, but the paper seems to underrepresent some of the ethical challenges of ethical review in a context of global inequality. It should be remembered, for example, that sponsoring countries hold the purse-strings, including the portion of the budget that is supposed to go to the local institutions for administrative support (including financial support for the local ethics committee). When there are conflicts between foreign and local ethics committees, which one is more likely to have the greatest say? The ethical playing field, parallel to the political and socio-economic playing fields, is very uneven. What might help, besides greater collaboration between ethics committees, is greater investment in local scientific institutions in order to prevent the vast majority of research being funded and conducted by developed world institutions.

Labels: , ,

25 Comments:

Blogger Samual said...

Its really interesting Blog. With growing number of private hospitals offering the best of medical services in the world, India has been evolving as a big mart for medical tourism business, which is reportedly growing at the rate of 30 per cent each year.

Orthopedic hospital India

8:45 AM  
Blogger Amal said...

I am from Egypt and I think your points are valid. Interestingly most local REC have been trained by the developed world which in a way help harmonize the review process since the members review research according to international standards put forth by the west.

8:27 PM  
Blogger will vdH said...

The global pervasiveness of ethics committees costs an estimated $500 million. And although these ethics committees also render judgment on social research, they are bio-medical committees and are dumbfounded sometimes by the essential requirements of social research.

5:32 PM  
Blogger Samual said...

Great Blog. It is also found that India represents the most potential medical tourism market in the world. Factors such as low cost, scale and range of treatments provided by India differentiate it from other medical tourism destinations.

Orthopedic hospital India

6:26 AM  
Blogger xclusivebusiness said...

Your information and writing style is no nice that anybody will be pleased.

2:30 AM  
Blogger xclusivebusiness said...

This is exclusive post. I am impressed by reading this.
Gender Aid

3:26 AM  
Blogger BackpackUnion said...

That is really a nice idea. It's nice that they have thought about that kind of way. Thanks for sharing this information.
I learned a lot of information about it. Thanks for sharing them. I will be expecting more of your posts in the future.
SwissGer Backpacks: Take 30%-50% off and enjoy FREE Shipping over $100, Ends 8/21/2011 @11PM PST

10:52 PM  
Blogger BackpackUnion said...

There is noticeably a bundle to learn about this. I assume you made sure nice points in features also. Replica Hermes Handbags | Cheap Louis Vuitton

10:12 PM  
Blogger correctme said...

Yes I agree this will be a great way to see things in a different perspective. skraplotter

6:14 PM  
Blogger danial11 said...

Welldone,I got useful information from your Blog.I will share this on facebook.Online Pharmacy

11:43 AM  
Blogger danial11 said...

I was searching some thing relevant to this, And i am feeling lucky, as its the perfect one for what i am looking for. I will share this. fitness trainer certification

12:11 PM  
Blogger Ricky jordan said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

6:10 AM  
Blogger Ricky jordan said...

Such a inspirable and good blog . I am able to get new knowledge while reading this . Keep sharing this type of informative blogs.
horoscope signs

6:11 AM  
Blogger john smith said...

I am agree with your Blog.Thanks for the useful information.I have been reading a lot of stuff about it. but the way in it is presented is nice.Here is the information about Production company.

8:05 AM  
Blogger john smith said...

I am agree with your Blog.Thanks for the useful information.I have been reading a lot of stuff about it. but the way in it is presented is nice.Here is the information about Production company.

8:05 AM  
Blogger Allen soly said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

1:27 AM  
Blogger Allen soly said...

Thanks for the update.There is a scope to reach out for the best with the power of information in our hands that i got from your blog.Gold Jewelry

1:29 AM  
Blogger Navneet Sau said...

Thank you for sharing such a informative stuff. I just came across this blog and find valuable things here. I would like to recommend it to my friends to get more interesting stuff.Lean Six Sigma

3:02 AM  
Blogger sarabrook11 said...

Very true.Such a nice concept. Your information is true up to great most of the extent. Thanks for sharing.Thanks for the useful information.Such a inspirable and good post . I am able to get new knowledge while reading this . Keep sharing this type of informative posts.

web video production

6:28 AM  
Blogger sano said...

I read from a site that methylhexanamine is synonym for dmma, so if you are searching for it you can get methylhexamine supplement effects I think you will find it their easily. Try it…

8:12 AM  
Blogger sano said...

5htp is said to be best supplement if anyone suffering from depression and anxiety, if you have severe problems you can overdose on 5-HTP but it is suggested by the experts that the quantity should not exceed to 300mg a day.

8:13 AM  
Blogger sano said...

The professional clarinet overhaul takes almost 2-4 days and plus one guarantee for one full year against defects in workmanship you can avail these on this site http://www.clarinet-repairs.com/overhauls.html

8:14 AM  
Blogger sano said...

from this site http://www.schizandrol.com/ i ordered some products in which schizandrol is an active ingredient. I want healthy skin, but it is also helpful in liver protection and memory loss treatment

8:15 AM  
Blogger astrolger best said...

Nice and quite useful post. Keep up the good work! love marriage specialist astrologer

12:45 PM  
Blogger Zheng junxai5 said...

2015-10-13 zhengjx
Coach Outlet Store Online Free Shipping
michael kors outlet
ugg boots sale
nike trainers
ugg boots australia
timberland boots
Coach Factory Outlet Official Coach Handbags Sale
canada goose outlet
Canada Goose Jackets Outlet Online Sale
michael kors outlet
Coach Factory Outlet Handbags 70% OFF
Gucci Outlet Online 80% OFF
michael kors outlet
cheap jordans,jordan shoes,cheap jordan shoes
michael kors outlet stores
Abercrombie And Fitch New York Outlet Store
cheap ugg boots
michael kors handbag
michael kors
Ralph Lauren UK Sale Polo Shirts
ugg boots
Up To 70% Off Air Retro Jordan 8s
coach factory outlet
Cheap Toms Shoes Outlet Sale Clearance
Louis Vuitton Handbags Factory Outlet
Michael Kors Outlet USA Store
Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Online
Air Jordan 4 Retro Free Shipping
coach outlet online
michael kors outlet

8:50 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home