Sunday, November 13, 2011

Unhealthy ethical signals in India's clinical trial world

Maybe I have been in this business a bit too long: I am starting to regard journalistic exposes about exploitive global health research in developing countries with (at least initially) with a jaded eye. This week The Independent newspaper is featuring a piece entitled Without consent: how drug companies exploit Indian 'guinea pigs'. The title itself is pushing all sorts of buttons: big Pharma + bad ethics + the vulnerable poor. But, as it stands, the content of the article only partially lives up to its vivid title. For those who read the original, consider the following:
  • The authors accuse researchers in India of not obtaining proper informed consent; participants are said to be not fully understanding what they sign up for. But full understanding is ever achieved in clinical trials conducted anywhere, including those with well-off, literate participants. There is more than a decade of bioethics literature on this.
  • A number of times, the authors state that there have been a number of deaths in clinical trials in India, and then later state that there has been no confirmed link between the deaths and study participation (including the use of the investigational drug). Unless a link is empirically proven, this is guilt by innuendo.
  • A number of persons provide soundbites about the Indian regulations of clinical trials being violated 'at every level' and on a regular basis. But concrete examples demonstrating grievous and widespread abuse -- or even detail on precisely what guidelines are being violated -- are not really on offer.
On the other hand, the journalists may have unearthed a couple of unethical nuggets. The Gates Foundation permitted local health authorities to empower headmasters to consent for their teenage girl students, i.e. the students were vaccine research participants without their or their parent's knowledge. If true, this is wrong. Since early this year, there have been accusations of 'enrolling' former victims of the Bhopal disaster into clinical trials without their knowledge. Again, if true, this is wrong. The editor of the Indian Journal of Medical Ethics states that he encountered fellow research ethics committee members unfamiliar with the practice of reading the protocol of the study they were reviewing. The practice of researcher/doctors investigating serious (fatal) adverse events in their own studies -- rather than having an independent body do so -- is cause for alarm. The concern about drugs being tested on those least capable of affording them is not new, but is still worth pointing out. And there have been numerous articles about the ethics of the clinical trial culture in India over the past five years: all this accumulative 'noise in the system' may reflect some serious and systematic wrongdoing. But you need verified and detailed facts to make it all stick.

There is an ethical tension in journalism between the pursuit of truth and the marketing of a compelling story. The whole narrative of global health research as a form of neo-colonialism, where the bodies of the poor are used and abused to make medicines for the bodies of the rich ... this story may be too attractive to pass up. The dodgy relationship between big Pharma and developing countries should be continually investigated, but we also need journalists who rake up some real dirt.


Blogger Fredrick M said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

11:32 AM  
Blogger Yogesh Kumar said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

3:36 AM  
Blogger imrookie said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

10:59 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

4:01 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

At condition with the aim of you are attract at home above testimonials as propos online casino roulette, so as to online casino be able to ameliorate you in amount of online casino slots

10:39 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

2015-10-13 zhengjx
Abercrombie And Fitch Clothing Outlet at New York
Louis Vuitton Handbags UK For Sale
uggs australia
Jordan 6 Retro Discount Sale
burberry outlet
Michael Kors Outlet Factory Online Store
celine handbags
michael kors bag
michael kors outlet
hollister uk
Louis Vuitton Handbags Official USA Website
Michael Kors Outlet Online 70% Off Handbags
michael kors bags
Michael Kors Outlet Online Store Clearance
coach factory outlet
Coach Outlet Online Coach Factory Outlet
Oakley Sunglasses Official Website Cheap Off
canada goose outlet
Coach Factory Outlet Official Website
Louis Vuitton Outlet Purses and Handbags For Sale
louis vuitton handbags
canada goose jackets
Louis Vuitton Outlet Store Locations
Michael Kors Outlet Factory Handbags For Sale
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet
Abercrombie And Fitch New York Clothing Warehouse
hollister clothing
Up to 70% Off Louis Vuitton Outlet
true religion outlet

8:41 PM  
Blogger chenlili said...

ray ban sunglasses
cheap air jordans
ray ban sunglasses
polo ralph lauren
hollister jeans
coach factory outlet
oakley outlet
ralph lauren polo
vans shoes
cheap louis vuitton handbags
ray ban sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses discount
rolex watches
air jordan 4
louis vuitton
beats by dr dre
michael kors outlet online
michael kors handbags
basketball shoes
adidas factory outlet
kate spade outlet
michael kors purses
christian louboutin shoes
michael kors outlet clearance
coach outlet store online clearances
coach factory outlet
michael kors handbags
coach factory outlet
abercrombie and fitch
michael kors handbags
coach outlet online
louis vuitton handbags
fitflops shoes
adidas shoes
pandora outlet
lebron 13
michael kors handbags
fitflop sale

9:51 PM  
Blogger raybanoutlet001 said...

ray ban sunglasses
mlb jerseys
cheap oakley sunglasses
eagles jerseys
jordan shoes
ugg outlet
michael kors outlet
ecco outlet
louis vuitton sacs
minnesota vikings jerseys

11:30 PM  
Blogger Nu Amoorea said...

This information is very useful. thank you for sharing. and I will also share information about health through the website

Cara Mengobati radang Usus
Cara Mengatasi sakit pundak dan Leher kaku
Cara Menghilangkan Benjolan di Bibir
Obat Nyeri haid
Tips Menghilangkan Wajah kusam
Cara Mengobati Bisul
solusi masalah kewanitaan

2:15 AM  
Blogger said...

Bangladesh Education Result Board & Government Official website. HSC Admission Result 2020 Recently Published. Government web. HSC Result Student can download HSC Admission Result PDF File.

10:52 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Bangladesh Bank Admit Card Recently published. Candidate first & easily download the Bangladesh Bank Admit Card & on our Government official website : Bangladesh Bank Admit Card Student can download Bangladesh Bank Admit Card PDF File.

3:34 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Directorate of Secondary & Higher Education (DSHE Admit Card) Published DSHE Admit Card. Student or Candidate first & easily download this DSHE Admit Card. Our Government official website : DSHE Admit Card .

5:44 AM  
Blogger exam results said... is an extensive educational portal. Students, parents,
teachers and educational institute can get Board Exam Result,
Admission, Academic Result, Career, Study Material for Assignments,
Institutes and latest Educations News in Bangladesh.

Exam Result:
BPSC is published the bcs exam result 2021 of preliminary,
written and viva exam on result website-

Bangladesh Education Board is published the hsc exam result 2021 online on
Download the full marksheet with number from here-

The Ministry of Education has published hsc admission result 2021 online for admission in higher secondary level in Bangladesh.

Full Resources:

official website:

2:22 PM  
Blogger said...

Get all Bangladesh education board result, Exam Routine, National University Result, HSC Result 2021, Alim Result 2021, JSC result 2021, HSC Admission Result, University Admission Circular, IPO Result 2021, Government Job in Bangladesh, and education news from our Government official website: Student or Candidate first & easily online University admission, Admit Card download, admission result, apply & download from our official website.

10:53 AM  
Blogger All New Result said...

20 General Science and Technology University is published the gst university admission test result on result page. students just need roll number to check the result.

2:45 AM  
Blogger exam results said...

National University is published the Honours 4th year exam result 2021 on result page. Students just need roll number and registration to check the result from website. In addition they can also check the result by sending an SMS.

12:20 AM  
Blogger said...

DSS Result 2021 The authority of the Department of Social Services result has been declared in update here. Now, Candidates check the result using roll number. Any Govt Job Results find this link- Results

7:05 AM  
Blogger said...

National University from all students protection has been published by the NU authority. students can (Covid-19) Vaccine Registration online as well our website - every information found.

2:18 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home